Ghost in the Shell: Arise 1 – Review

[Commie] Ghost in the Shell Arise - 01 [BD 720p AAC] [A7CD8D76].mkv_00:10:00_07-03-13

At the top of the cyberpunk hill stands the Ghost in the Shell franchise. First formulated in concept by Masamune Shirow, it has been Mamoru Oshii’s Ghost in the Shell (1995) film and Kenji Kamiyama’s Standalone Complex series that have amassed wide and overwhelmingly positive reception. Ghost in the Shell: Arise—a four-part OVA series—is the most recent installment into the franchise, serving as a prequel set prior to Section 9’s establishment. With high expectations coming from a new Ghost in the Shell title, it may not come as a surprise that Arise’s first piece (Border:1 Ghost Pain) wields variable success.

Perhaps one of the most noticeable changes in Arise is the single point of view focus onto Motoko. Her actions and behavior play off as slightly more human in the OVA, whether it be displaying discernible facial expressions or occasionally acting by emotion. This causes her to seem more like her physical age than her typical, cold and cryptic self. Additionally, she holds more bearing on the story than normal. Aiming to solve a murder and later being implicated as the primary suspect, Motoko becomes pivotal in whether Arise can subtly yet powerfully grasp its story.

[Commie] Ghost in the Shell Arise - 01 [BD 720p AAC] [A7CD8D76].mkv_00:10:34_07-03-13

As a teaser and opener, Border:1 does a decent job. The mystery remains simple while still wafting that old GITS tension; it nicely paces through the narrative on tried and true grounds. The investigations murk about, action scenes go a-flurry, and exciting plot twists make the sketches of a solid storyline. Motoko also receives hints of development through a partially grasped backstory, and while this may seem incomplete, Border:1 is after all only one of four entries, and the allusions toward more (particularly Motoko’s development and thorough introductions to future Section 9 members) work seamlessly into the storytelling.

Yet, this is also one of Arise’s pitfalls. The simple plot structure—combined with a singular point of view and occasionally awkward pacing—can cause a few scenes to feel slightly linear and dull. Moreover, the restrictive point of view may narrow the scope of the OVA’s aims, and GITS’s recurring characters (namely, Araki, Batou, and Togusa) make a nice cameo but that’s about it.

This leaves a lurking, uneasy feeling about the work’s direction; many of the sci-fi themes prevalent in previous titles are also non-existent here. However, what’s fortunate is that Arise manages to keep many of the subtleties and charm within the character dialogues intact. It may not exactly feel like the GITS we’ve all come to learn and love, but it’s still a good sci-fi story nonetheless.

[Commie] Ghost in the Shell Arise - 01 [BD 720p AAC] [A7CD8D76].mkv_00:28:56_07-03-13

Much of the streamlined narrative can also be attributed to the limited time allocated in Arise. After all, a one-hour treat can only do so much into framing the beginning, middle, and ends of a mystery. However, this limitation is surely not the only factor causing simplifications in the work; the villains come and go, the action scenes are numerous yet not always relevant to the plot, and certain dialogues seem out of place and unrequired. Still, at the heart of Arise’s content lie the fundamental pieces which provide for good writing.

[Commie] Ghost in the Shell Arise - 01 [BD 720p AAC] [A7CD8D76].mkv_00:38:23_07-03-13

While Arise’s visuals proudly stands with its own style, its design choices have stirred controversy. The OVA beautifully flourishes a lighter opacity than previous installments. This luminosity offers a fresher appeal, leaving a tonal vibrance that nicely captures the ages of the slightly younger cast. However, paired with the more minimalist detail and brighter shade of skin tones, this can at times apprehend viewers. Motoko’s character design, for instance, almost (note: almost) has that moe appeal trending among current shows. This no doubt has spurred contentions among the loins of all otaku and self-appraising viewers. Fortunately, what rare fanservice does exist encapsulates the same seinen bloodshed-and-boobies common in the genre. In other words, you won’t be seeing Motoko pull off an Asuka catchphrase any time soon.

The soundtrack remains true to the cyberpunk theme, offering circuits of electronic pop, jazz, and smooth guitar riffs. The choreography and overall animation are generally both fluid and topknotch, oozing out creativity with Arise’s integration of cybertechnology in action scenes—realtime hacking wizardry, cybernetic organs, and quick-fire CQC. The 3D CGI works just as well as in Stand Alone Complex, with little to no intrusive vices; it’s great to know these elements have (for the most part) marched the classic beat encased within the GITS franchise.

[Commie] Ghost in the Shell Arise - 01 [BD 720p AAC] [A7CD8D76].mkv_00:24:54_07-03-13

With mixed success in its execution, Arise still serves as an admirable entry point into a new tetralogy. Production IG proves that its animation and visuals are still ever improving, and Arise’s plot—while “off”—makes a decent segway for the next three titles to come along. Whether one is a fan of Border:1 or not, high hopes remain for the upcoming installments.

Score: Good (6/10)


  1. So, I’m quite sure that’s my worst review yet. I like some paragraphs (for example, the two production value ones), but I think the rest really lack something. The flow is awkward between some sentences, the intro is a really generic history lesson (practically in cloned style to my Nekomono review, though I do like the “cyberpunk hill” idiom), and the second paragraph is really really ill-suited. This is particularly important considering the first two, maybe three paragraphs, are what most readers skim through before deciding if the rest is a worth a shot. Ain’t looking too great when my best paragraphs are the second to last two.

    Meh, I guess what I’ll work on next is improving sentence flow, retaining my normal casual-humor writing style, and keep the paragraphs more cohesive rather than so blandly categorized. Normal structured reviews like this one may not be my thing.

    I give this review a (6/10). (jk)

    1. This is the first time I see author reviews his own review in the comments. Quite interesting approach, I must say.

      I would rate it higher as I see the focus on only one perpesctive a conscious and right decision of the director. There wasn’t really much to show from future section 9 members point of view as they are yet to become those badasses we know – as a result of what will be shown in next episodes, the forming of the section. There isn’t much time to spare them now either.

      I have one thing that made me grit my teeth while reading your post. You should not call this music dubstep. That’s like calling an elephant a pet animal. Shure, you can pet one, but it makes no sense whatsoever.

      1. Thanks for the feedback! Changed the dubstep part (I know nothing about electronic music).

        I feel the overall story structure lacked a little of what makes the story a GITS one. The basic elements are there—primarily the plot points—but much more of the complexity seems missing, either in the mystery itself, or the characters. As for the decision of the POV, it seems ill-placed to have Arise 1 as some marginally out of the way teaser and then start introducing and assembling the Section 9 team. There doesn’t seem to be a point of the first OVA if it doesn’t actually establish very much.

  2. donreba · · Reply

    This review pretty much echoes my own thoughts after watching Arise. I would have probably been more negative, had I written something on the subject.

    1. Thanks for the comment. Glad to know my thoughts aren’t only one-sided. With three more titles being issued along, I want to be optimistic and say that they’re just saving the best parts for later. But even being lenient, this OVA may be the worst entry in the franchise.

  3. The kind of services deals transcribing general hospital dentistry, subspecialties of dental medicine,
    orthodontics, oral pathology, endodontics, periodontics,
    prosthodontics, dental pharmacology as well as radiography.
    The sole reason for this is so that they do not render their orthodontic courses redundant
    by not keeping up. The synthetization and accumulation of large
    amount of extracellular matrix play the key role of causing renal

  4. I quite enjoyed Arise, especially the animation. Have you seen/reviewed Mardock Scramble? I read earlier, here that it’s quite similar to GitS and I’d be interested to hear if you’d recommend that?


Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: